radbadchad: Nice start. With the moon being right behind the scene like that I’d expect to see a lot more light being cast by it, perhaps even making it the key light source. There are a few areas which are overbright, in particular the carousel and under the Ferris Wheel. Try to add falloff to your lights and/or decrease their intensity.
xeltestic: Good work. I can’t figure out exactly what the shadow is on the ground. It may be the perspective that’s making it difficult to read. The spot light on the balloon is very similar in color to the diffuse light on the carousel. It may help to separate different areas of the scene with different light colors to show more depth.
pmcb: Nice image. The foreground materials have a nice quality to them and the atmosphere is off to a good start. Overall I think the image could use some more contrast. The pillars in the foreground have nice shading, each side has a different brightness. If the you could get some more shaping of the Carousel with light it would look a little less flat.
preetamsaha: I like this new render a lot. You’ve matched a lot of the light sources well with the backplate in particular the lights on the Carousel’s top. I’d like to see some more specular highlights on the balloons, they should be nearly as bright as the light sources themselves. Specular reflections are one of the main things that tell us what material an object is made out of. I’d like to see some more work with highlights on the other objects in the scene as well.
PPGINGRAS: Interesting take so far. It’s hard to tell where the lights motivation is coming from. Keep going!
ranjan3dlighting: Good work. The light sources in your image match the backplate pretty well but they don’t seem to be casting much light. The tent in the back is lit very evenly, try to get some more shaping on the object.
dzazaleo: Welcome! Very nice image so far. The balloons and metal could use some stronger specular highlights, especially since they’re reflecting the sun. You may want to change the backplate, it seems to be a little too low resolution for the image. You may also want to mix up your materials a little bit, objects are getting lost when they’re next to each other. Notice how well the contrast of the wood on the floor of the carousel works in contrast to the ceiling.
VinVang69: Interesting take. I like the idea of the red eyes on the horses. I’d like to see some light being emitted from the eyes. It’s hard to see what direction the light is coming from. Try to create some nice shaping of the objects.
avnishjha: Nice start. There seems to be a lot of ambient light, especially for a night scene. Try to keep all your lights motivated.
lilnamz: Good update. Since the carousel has visible light sources I would expect the brightest part of the horses to be on the tops of them. Keep in mind that bounce light is only as bright as the illumination of the surface the light is bouncing off of.