Okay here are the test I had one of the guys did. He did it in C4D but we get roughly the same results across all our aplications.
Obviously to see the difference, I can’t compress it. So here is a link to 4 different render showing the different versions, with the settings on each page… (The files size is about 25 MBs.)
http://www.rendertitan.com/RenderTITAN AA_testrenders2.zip
On the image that is Quad-Sized, I downsampled it already so that all the images are the same size for comparison purposes. I also included adaptive sampling for comparison as well. Adaptive is not bad for a still, but for an animation it flickers very badly.
Also, the Quad-Sized version aso holds mode detail. It seems that the render holds the detail at that rendered intent resolution so the Quad-size is Quad-Detailed and can be seen in the downsampled one as well. It also seems that the Quad size treats the scene better, which is most noticabl in the front center with the blue reflection.
Render fast but render smart!
Mark
RenderTITAN
EDIT: The render times are at the bottom left of each image.