C4D(R23)-Cut or Connect Points - Does not work properly

#1

I noticed that the Connect Points and Cut Tool do not work properly in R23, but in R18 they work properly.
Has something changed in the R23, do you have the same problems, is that a bug?
Here is C4D file.
Thanks in advance!

Connect_Points_R23-NotWorking
Connect_Points_R23-NotWorking.JPG753x462 20.9 KB

Connect_Points_R18-Working
Connect_Points_R18-Working.JPG955x331 31 KB

Connect_Points.zip (51.8 KB)

#2

Are the top and bottom images supposed to depict the same action in R23 and R18 ?

#3

Exactly, Top is R23 Bottom R18.

#4

Well, since R18 there’s been a lot of changes …

Maybe there is no update to your viewport because the underlying triangular mesh is exactly the same as depicted in the bottom picture. When I removed the N-gons, your model had the same structure as in R18 picture.

The fact that the Connect Points does not split your original model to 3 N-Gons could be an optimization feature added later.

Which of these doesn’t work for you ?
Screenshot_2

#5

Thank you for your effort, Line Cut dont work but only in R23.

#6

I found out that after using the boolean operation Connect and Line Cut no longer work,
does anyone else have the same problem?

grafik
grafik.jpg1602x863 163 KB

Connect_Points_AfterBooleDontWork.zip (60.0 KB)

#7

“Single Object” checked ? Otherwise run a optimzie comand with corect tolerance ?

Neveretheless since R22 a lot of modelling tools are “buggy” I have 3 Tickest open at Maxon …

#8

Thank you for your commitment, I tried everything, also optimize it … it works in R18, I also believe that this is a bug.