Hey Lee, a few thoughts about your scene.
I understand it’s still in progress, but might give you a few ideas, anyway …
Keep an eye on the black points, first of all the background plate seems a little high in contrast. The Smoke needs to be much darker to match the plate, play around with the levels/curve in AE and match the blacks to that of your plate. That said i’d first pull the plate back a little then match the smoke to that.
When using AE, do most of the grading in AE itself so you can work with the CG at the same time, i’m guessing you graded the backplate in PS then imported into AE?
Regarding composition, i’d think about a different angle for the meteors, crossing the frame like that seems less exciting, maybe you could have them passing over the camera from slightly behind to the left, with a little camera shake, giving the impression they’re a lot closer.
I’d also like to see a little more internal glow/fire, at least 25% further up the shaft.
I’d also be tempted to begin the shot with a few distant meteors breaking through the clouds quite slowly, then introduce the two forground.
Over all looking good 
- Dave.






