I like what you have done so far, add a little more rust on the ladder espicilly the upper part of the ladder.
Scene: inspired by Half Life 2
Much nicer! well done, looking really good now. I even like it with no sky, seems more ‘half lifey’,
Try adding in some wooden creates like there was, or oil drums. Only a few though, don’t want to make it too cramped in.
when I said half life, I ment, industry, oil rigs, electric grid lines, HALF LIFE ART !!! This is a wip 
That looks like Half Life art to me! 
Reminds me of several levels in the game.
I still think your water is to dark and solid, but like they say it’s art.
Hi, Critical. Amazing work you got here. I’ll give it five stars just becaouse of that nice lightning that you have. The overall picture is really great but I would remove those wires around the pool , I believe it would be nicer to the eye to concentrate on big picture and not on the details. Good job, thought
fixed some stuff, fixed the fence texture, I broke that red light on the right :), better color correction… hmm, I still need at least 1 small detail before I get on with the bigger things, outside the scene… any suggestions

I think it’s a bit too light now, maybe slighty darker but only a bit. Hum, for the oudside, maybe some of those big buildings near the end of HL2 (where you loose ‘Dog’), or some big tall building to fill it up.
EDIT: Actually the lightness looks ok.
This is just getting better and better - goes to show that a little feedback goes a long way! Im glad you got rid of the skull!
Looks real nice so far - nice contrast between white concrete and the dark stains around the water level. The only crit i can make is that the red-ish metal wheel on the left seems very big given the comparative size of the ladder. Im not too keen on the HL2 logo either…
Nice work - whats next?
Perhaps you could add a few plants or something. Or perhaps some floating rubbish etc…
![]()
well, I fixed the textures, bumping, and made a bigger render. Notice that there are some grafits from the actuall game 

Looks very stylish, I like it alot. But one thing I figured out, it’s only a minor thing, so not very hard to fix. The “frame” of the rotor at the right side is too edgy, too lowpoly, please fix it. 
Frankly that was looking shite at the beginning, I thought to myself ‘Here we go another gamer trying to do r@d 3D’. Boy was I wrong, the scene has turned out beautifully!
Awesome texture work and renders ![]()
Wow, this is exelent now! I’m not too keen on the 2 graffit’s next to each other though. To finish it off I think wooden creates would look great in it - as you always saw them in HL2.
Keep up the good work,
Really really cool scene.
Just one thing; white sky makes this pic a bit empty: you have filthy scene down and clean sky up. I would go with storming sky. Just an idea.
Nice work
I can’t wait to see this scene with well chosen lighting… it’s gonna get creepy for sure
Haha…I love this scene… its beautifullly lit.
I’d love to throw a character of mine in it.
Heh.
Good luck with this.
Wow this looks beautiful. I love this scene. Great job and love the lighting as well.
This is lookin’ really sweet.
The textures, render, lighting, everything, look fantastic.
from me.
-eric