Hi there Dave,
They’ll just need some kind of very subtle flickering, or some kind of “movement” similar to flickering but maybe not as fast as a typical flicker.
Try this, assuming your stars on on their own layer. Duplicate the layer, put it in “add” or “Screen” mode, and add a fast or Gaussian blur. Then above that layer, create a new solid, color doesn’t matter. Add a “fractal noise” to that solid layer, and dial down the scale, and maybe turn down the complexity a tiny bit. “Alt - click” the stopwatch next to the evolution setting (this allows you to enter an expression to control that parameter), and type
time*100
Now the noise animates. Later on, if it’s going too fast or slow, try numbers higher or lower than 100.
Now precomp this layer, call it something like “noise map”.
Below this layer, on your blurred star layer, change the track matte setting (right to the right of the blending mode setting) to “luma”. This will only show the blurred, glowy stars where the noise pattern is white, and because it’s in motion, it will be “flickering” and oscillating. Of course, adjust the speed, opacity of the glow layer, amount of blur, all that stuff. You could even duplicate the whole setup, offset the noise map layer (so its not the same as the first noise map layer), and maybe do a different set of settings, like smaller tighter glows, or maybe throw a color balance on and introduce some very slight color.
Just some thoughts…