Very very very wonderful environment!Impressive!!
congratulations!
cheers
Absolutly gorgeous Raph, congrats, your style never stops to evolve!
I really like the way you work, it really feels like you concentrate on the composition and mood, and the overhall picture is full of energy and vibrations…
five stars for me, and front page material for sure!
i think that mods at cgtalk should seriously start to think about a matte painting only thread 
hint hint
Great work!!
As always, you’re stuff is a great source of inspiration for me!!
I love how you get all the information across with an almost impressionistic touch of details.
Great mood and atmosphere… I just love those trees!! I think they really add to the creepy feel of your image.
Light! it is geat! 5x5 stars 
However for me this painting remind (i don’t know why)
Baginskis movie - “Cathedral”
It´s like you could become to breathe the atmosphere of your composition and the smoke:) Good work!!
┤ Zalo
Hey…are you crazy? That`s beautifle, very…very nice atmosphere, I feel depth here so much.Sorry, but only 5* from me
:shrug: friend. 
Excellent work, Raphael!
I love the atmosphere, the mood, the lighting-colours… and the composition. A great sample of staging.
Five stars from me.
ohhhh Realy nice … like a dream . keep it uper than up …
http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?t=310136
http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?t=309509
http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?t=303752
http://forums.cgsociety.org/showthread.php?t=304343
The painting is great, but some credit should be given to Caspar David Friedrich (http://www.usc.edu/schools/annenberg/asc/projects/comm544/library/images/142.html).
Yes, that’s the very first thing that ran through my mind as well when I saw El Rafo’s excellent rendering. I’d say you’re in good company to invoke such a complimentary comparison ![]()
Masterful work, thx for sharing with us.
Caspar David Friedrich - Cloister Graveyard in the Snow, 1810
“If you shoot, shoot to kill!”
Great atmosphere, congrats!
(et pour bien nous achever, ça se la tappe “j’ai fait ça en 3 minutes pour m’amuser” haha)
:shrug: