ericyeo,
Wow! That’s looking really good. You’ve got some nice subtle shadows that really make the piece, like the area behind his left knee.
The shadow on his butt seems a bit harsh though…in that it makes it appear that he has a “bubble butt”. Also the muscle shadow on his right calf seems a bit strong…it ends up looking very flexed, rather than relaxed. Those were the elements that stood out to me.
zhuzhu,
That’s really nice, looks like you have a good handle on working with ink. I really love that style and so far haven’t had any luck with it, practice practice practice!
Do you plan on developing this any further? I’d really be curious to see what you might do with it.
SaraD,
I really like the tone of your shadows. I often find myself making shadows black when it’s not appropriate.
I like your color scheme too, though I’m less sure about the redder areas. Those seem to make his skin look a bit splotchy. I wouldn’t call that unrealistic lighting either, it looks like he’s bathed in moonlight. Very nice!