anshad06: Good job! With the carousel being the brightest part of the image I’m surprised to not see any strong reflections especially on the balloons. The light sources on the Ferris wheel in the back are very blurry compared to the lights on the buildings on the back plate and on the opposite end the lights in the foreground don’t seem to have any glow. Try to balance this out.
jojo1975: Nice atmosphere, very dreamy. I took a look at your images histogram and it seems to be lacking some dark values. For example, where the carousel meets the ground is fairly bright. On the other hand, some areas look to be a little to bright. As an example, even though the horses are covered by a roof some of them are still blown-out. Try taking a look at the dark values in on the castle in the backplate and incorporate that contrast into your image.
livuxman: Good update! Nice work, since the image is still cloudy, as I know you’re planning on changing =), the lighting isn’t quite as interesting as it could be. I’m looking forward to your next update! As for your animation it looks pretty nice. One thing I did notice is that you may need to turn up your bokeh sampling when the balloons go out of focus.
gomes21: Nice! My main critique would be to adjust the DOF. With such a shallow DOF of a distant object it makes the image look like a miniature. Try to make the DOF much deeper where the middle ground will have a much larger depth that’s in focus.
okcannon: Nice start. As a silhouette the image looks good but could be a little more interesting in the concern of lighting. Perhaps some reflections of the sky?
rpadc2002: Looks like some intriguing studies. Interested to see some more.
fredduck: I really like this image, great job!
coolayan: Great image! As you said the motion blur on the Ferris wheel could be a little more subtle, especially for the time of day. Maybe some blur on the carousel as well? The shading on the balloons looks a little flat and even, I’d like to see a little more shaping on them.
tanmoycgartist: Nice update! I’d still like to see some brightre values to break up the the midtones in the image. For example the bench looks fairly evenly lit on every side. Try to differentiate each side of the bench with different values. It’s also a little hard to see everything in the image, next time you may want to put up a bigger image.