chronic brought up a good point, that lens distortion will end up complicating this a bit.
I still think it would be helpfull for some of the contestants to have the footage pre-tracked. However, the distortion corrected plates would have to be given to everyone along with the track solution. The only downside to this, speaking from a Boujou standpoint, is that each contestant will not be able to get the native lens distortion back.
This is where Roberto could provide the footage (both tracked and with the lens distortion corrected), yet also state that if the contestant so desires he/she could track it themselves.
I still say that it would be pretty cool to have a mini-matchmoving challenge before each FXWARS. I have never really seen a challenge of this sort at CGTalk before and it is certainly an art. This all could take place durring the voting of the previous FXWARS.
Just an idea…