FXWars! RollerCoaster!: Sir_Vulcan

#1

Ok, This is my first try at any competition here, hope I dont come in last. Anyways here’s my first tests. It doesnt look like much yet, but I wanted to get the Physics setup first, then I’ll work on the design and modeling. I am using Max6 and Reactor 2.

I only have two cars so far, to setup the main wheels and links between cars. Ill add more later including the under and (maybe) inner wheels.

:bounce:
LINK TO FINISHED COASTER PAGE
http://www.cgtalk.com/showthread.php?p=1766635&posted=1#post1766635

#2

Few More…

#3

Hey, looking nice. But what about turns? :stuck_out_tongue:

#4

Got an update, I finally got it to go over the loop, theres to much drag some where. Hopefully my new version will work better.

Anyways here’s one of my tests .mov
http://www.uni-weimar.de/~rehberg/vulcan/CarPhysicsTest03.mov

Tell me what you think…

#5

Ok, im having a lot of trouble with the banking around turns and loops and such. I have tried to use splines, NURBS, and bones.

The spline won’t let me control the banking and often banks the wrong way or just makes a complete flip.
The NURBS is great for controling banking with the 2-rail extrude, but then it scales the track to fit between the lines, so my rollercoaster can’t go down it because the track changes shape.
the bone idea that Ironlips is using is really nice, but he’s using Lightwave and I cant seem to find such a nice feature like that in 3Ds max6. I know it has the spline IK chain, but I have to make each and every bone, and then go back and change the height so there all the same.

I have also thought of just using a mesh and then extruding and moving, extruding and moving, but that would take forever to do, and no easy way to edit the track once is done.

If anyone could give me a tip as to how to control the banking, that would be very nice.

thanks

#6

One way to do the banking could be using the loft tool. Create the spline for the path and the shapes for the shape to be extruded along the spline and then after lofting you can edit the “twist” graph under deformations or something like that, so that you can get the shape of the track right.

#7

ya, thats what I ended up doing earlier today, I had tried lofting before but I was doing it backwords. I was picking the shape and lofting it along a line, instead of picking the line and lofting the shape. I think I have it all figured out now. Ill be posting another testing clip soon. Then I think I am ready to make the complete track and work on the visual part.

Thanks for the tip

#8

Ok, here’s an update. On the fourth version of the cars, and I got the loft and banking to work right. http://www.uni-weimar.de/~rehberg/vulcan/CarPhysicsTest04.mov

Time to make the entire track and start adding details.

#9

Nice setup! Seems to work very well!

André

#10

the thing usually doesnt slow donw on loops tho

#11

Ok, here is my track design. I might have to change a few things depending on the physics, but the shape is there. Ill post a picture of the cars soon too, so you can see how they are setup.

So, what do you think?

#12

here’s the car setup I have right now, I was originally planning on four rows of people, but I think the cars might be too long to bend properly around the track. So I might make it into two rows per car, and six cars per train.

#13

Update on the track. It’s a real pain to get this thing to bank right, expecially on the looping parts where the track flips over. I have to go through foot by foot and edit the twist curve. And on the loops the angles on twisting can go from +125 degrees to -154 degrees in just a fraction of an inch. Theres got to be an easier way.:shrug: oh well. it works.

Note: I’ve only gotten to the first corkscrew with the banking.

#14

looks good.

Do you use two curves, one for path and one for twist?

If so… make the second one a clone of the first one and move each
control point a lil bit along the normal of the of the first one as the
start… makes it easier to tweak…

#15

“It’s a real pain to get this thing to bank right”

Yeah, welcome to the club. This is really a pain. The funny thing is when you try to spread the mountings of the main tubes along the track. The “banking” of the tubes was done with the twist curve. For the mountings you use the spline (with the pacing tool). There´s no way to get the twisting information into the spline so the mountings have to be rotated each by each. Or did I miss something?

André

#16

laluneverte: No, I am only using one spline (and then editing the twist curve in the lofts Deformaiton properties) I don’t know how to use another spline for twisting the track. :shrug: I am using max 6, so if you have any suggestion feel free to share them.

ACantarel: lucky for me my track is solid, so I dont have to worry about the supports between the rails. I will have to make the track supports (by hand) but that shouldn’t be hard.

#17

ACantarel: I had the same problem when trying to attach the ties. But it seemed that once I messed with the axis orientation and stuff, it actually did follow the twist using the loft. The screen that is in my topic shows those ties, I made the ties, then used the spacing tool along the original spline, and it actually did bank itself to the loft. It was strange, and I am still trying to figure out how it did that. I can get it to work on like straight hills, but I will try some banked curves in a few hours and see if I can get it work…

One question for Sir_Vuclan though, how do you plan on doing supports?

I haven’t tried it yet, but only ideas I have are to either model every support, or use splines to connect the track and footers, then loft a shape onto those splines… but I would like to hear your input…

#18

I think I am just planning on using splines and lofting the supports or in some cases just make the spline renderable. I haven’t thought about it to much, Working on getting the track built so I can test to make sure the cars make it all the way around. Then after it all works, Ill add everything else.

#19

Ok, new version of…almost everything.

Updated:
Cars (made them shorter to bend around track better)
added more cars
fixed track
tweaked Reactor more

http://www.uni-weimar.de/~rehberg/vulcan/CarPhysicsTest06.mov

Its getting there…

#20

I have the coaster working around most of the track now. This clip doesnt show all of it, but you get the idea. I have a lifting device (box following a spline) to get it up the hill.

I have also started to work on the enviroment around the coaster.

Link to the newest Movie:
http://www.uni-weimar.de/~rehberg/vulcan/CarPhysicsTest07.mov