|05 May 2010||#1|
GROUND STUDIOS GmbH
3D animation & visual FX
Join Date: Feb 2002
Photoshop and Gamma are no friends!
Is it just me, or is Photoshop (CS4) unable to add a correct Gamma onto linear footage?
I have a client in the print business. I offered him a great benefit in realism of our 3D work if we keep the workflow linear.
After approval of some jpg previews (of cause WITH Gamma), I rendered out all elements in max as 16bit tiffs with 1.0 gamma.
I put them together to perfectly match the Beauty tiff, but when I added an Exposure Adjustment layer and set the gamma to 2.2, in oder to get the gamma correted Version (as approved) Photoshop did it completely different from Max. I get perfect result with fusion gamma 2.2 does exactly what max shows in the framebuffer.
Look at this image:
The image on the right should look exactly like the left one. PS failed completely. the dark areas are brightened up too much. the whole thing lost contrast.
What I ended up with was a selfmade curve to match gamma as close as possible, but hey this is not professional.
Is there a way to add correct Gamma in Photoshop?
Last edited by DerPapa : 05 May 2010 at 01:09 AM.
|05 May 2010||#2|
huddersfield, United Kingdom
Join Date: Jul 2006
the main problem is that photoshop is an image editor program, not a compositing program like fusion. photoshop doesnt work in floating point, so this may be where the problem is occuring.
|05 May 2010||#4|
Join Date: Mar 2010
I would never save a linear image (gamma 1.0) in a non floating point format. Those are not capable of holding all the information.
And you should change the gamma with the levels dialog. Just set the value of the center field to 2.2.
This should give you a better result.
RenderPal V2 - Render Farm Manager
http://www.renderpal.com - Version 2.14 Out Now!
Official Team member
|05 May 2010||#5|
Join Date: Sep 2003
Thread automatically closed
Note that as CGTalk Members, you agree to the terms and conditions of using this website.
|Thread Closed share thread|