CGTalk > Work in Progress and Critique > WIP/Critique: 3D
Login register
Thread Closed share thread « Previous Thread | Next Thread »
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 07-17-2003, 05:45 PM   #1
dgarrison
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 9
Animation: "DAMN KNIGHT" short film...

"DAMN KNIGHT"short film


Hi Everyone

I posted this up cause I completed an animated short that took me two years to make. I wanted to let you all in on it and see what you think. I am an artist like all of you, and have chosen character animation as my skill focus. It took me so long to make this because i have to work 6 days a week to pay the bills....

I am hoping that this will showcase my skills, so that i may get work finally. Anyway, I hope you all enjoy it and please tell me what you think....Thank you all in advance for taking a look

O yea, incase anyone wanted to know, I did everything from storyboarding, to voice over, animation, design, set up etc....

Dave
__________________
www.sillyshports.com/dgarrison
garrison.dave@verizon.net
 
Old 07-17-2003, 07:04 PM   #2
Volker
Incurable God Lover
 
Volker's Avatar
Zach Volker
Character Animator
Infinity Ward
Los Angeles, USA
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 234
Dave, I think you've created a really nice little piece. There are a couple areas that I'd continue to work on. First, the model of the knight was pretty distracting, mainly his face. The animation was not too bad, though there were a couple of parts that were a little shady. Why a knight would be trying to teach an alien to fight is beyond me, so right off the bat it was a tough sell. I finally got it in the end, but I as still a little confused. Maybe have some stage hands come on screen or the director at the end. Great job for doing everything yourself. Hope you find work.
~Zach
 
Old 07-18-2003, 04:33 PM   #3
dgarrison
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 9
Hey BabyHoper thanks



I really appreciate the feedback, and hehehe your right what in the world, why would a knight be teaching an alien how to fight is crazy, but thats why i did it. I wanted to do something diffrent, something that would make you say HU...and have to watch it until the end. I hope thats what i accomplished. As far as the feedback goes, thanks allot for taking the time out, and looking in on DAMN KNIGHT. At the end, yea i can see having a stage hand or two walking around checking lighting or something. I guess after animating the four characters and the time it took, never thought of it. But yea it would really add to the ending. If you thought the animation itself though wasn't bad at all then maybe, I just might have done something good right. thanks again for all of your comments, and take care....

Dave.
__________________
www.sillyshports.com/dgarrison
garrison.dave@verizon.net
 
Old 07-18-2003, 05:39 PM   #4
DOMINICHI
New Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 18
I know your concentrating on becoming an animator, but you have given the lighting absolutley no consideration. it doesnt matter what a great idea for a story you have or how funny the end joke is. If its dull to look at then people arent going to waste there time to watch it all. I only sat through it all because Im a little bored here, but your short doesnt work, its painful to watch, badly lit, composited, acted, animated, but most importatnly isnt funny.
 
Old 07-18-2003, 08:27 PM   #5
dgarrison
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 9
Does someone need a HUG?????

Easy there cowboy, rage pills are available at your local clinic.

If my lighting hurt your eyes that much then I'm sorry, but i never said that I was a lighitng specialist, for that matter an effects animator, or a jack of all trades, simply character animation. I never even mentioned anything about compositing, so i don't know where you got that either. Straight rendering sorry......
I did give this out as an open invitation to give opinons and thoughts so thats fine if you feel that way. I don't expect to make everyone happy. I will always be working in all areas of animation, so one day i will say that i am a jack of all trades. I'm here to learn and improve... and now for you....

Your reply does tell me something. If you can come to a place like this, have a collection of artists and there work to look at and learn from at your finger tips and say you are BOARD, then maybe you should concider unsubscribing. Maybe your just upset that someone else did something that you could not do. Have you ever made a 3 plus minute short all by yourself...HMMMMMM....

O well, thanks again for watching my entire movie because you were board.. either way in the end you watch the whole thing so that tells us all that it's not as bad as you say it is...Good luck with your life, let alone with your career.
Dave. ........remember rage pills.
__________________
www.sillyshports.com/dgarrison
garrison.dave@verizon.net
 
Old 07-20-2003, 11:33 AM   #6
}-{obbes
Veteran
 
}-{obbes's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 94
I have to agree with Dom, the story was just not interesting. But to make how it looks better i can at least give a little input.
The wings on the butterfly seem too stiff as well as too thick. The lip movements of the knight were really bad i have to say. As the other guy was sayin, put in stage hands etc at the end, to help get the point across. Like right when the alien walks away the guy that holds the long mic on a pole could like "relax" a bit and it dips into the picture, maybe a clapboard ending the take, though i dunno if thats done anyways, and maybe some more camara jiggle like the camaraman stepped away from it, either way its pretty fluid at the end during the director speaking when if that guy knocked himself out 5 times already the camaraman would probably be tired.
One last thing, you should probably change the title, doesn't really go with it that well.
 
Old 07-21-2003, 09:24 AM   #7
DOMINICHI
New Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 18
If you found my criticism hard to take then I apologize, but maybe you should ask yourself some serious questions, if you can't take on board some helpful advice then maybe you shouldn't be posting here. I realize you are only concentrating on the animation, but this still should never mean you ignore other really important areas like compostion and lighting. Overall the animation isn't bad and alot better than I can do. But then again I never said I could, and your arguement that you can only comment if you can do better is slightly immature. I only commented on your work to help you, nothing else.
 
Old 07-21-2003, 05:12 PM   #8
dgarrison
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 9
a simple conversation

Hello Dominichi,

atleast this time, you sound a-bit more calm than the last. I want you to re-read what you said :I only sat through it all because Im a little bored here, but your short doesnt work, its painful to watch, badly lit, composited, acted, animated, but most importatnly isnt funn
If you were me, and i said that to you, you would think that was very sarcastic and rude. That is not helpful advice That's not called a critigue, thats why i said what i said to you. :shame:

Dominichi if you want to give advice to someone thats fine, but there are allot better ways of doing it then your attempt to me, as well as you need to read what people say before you comment, it can get you in trouble in the work force if you don't pay attention to what they say. ENOUGH
Out of all of this, you did make me think about those other areas, and you are right, as an artist, you do have to pay attention to all detail not just one thing when you make a full scene, so you did help me after all.
ok so now that we all know what i am trying to do, hows about you letting me see what it is you do, or atleast trying to do....
what do you say....

Dave
__________________
www.sillyshports.com/dgarrison
garrison.dave@verizon.net
 
Old 07-21-2003, 06:08 PM   #9
DOMINICHI
New Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 18
This is getting silly now. you've taken my comments completely wrong. I don't know if your in the industry or not, I am, so am used to criticism. You WILL need to learn to take criticism better. If you can honestly say that you are 100 percent happy with your movie then why post it in the first place? You said you made this movie to get a job, and I stand by what I said, I found it painful to watch, don't you think a potential employer could think the same? Lighting is extremely important, if you want to sell your short as best you can then make it beautiful to look at, at the momment the overall look of your movie detracts from the animation.
As for you wanting to see what I do, Im not playing that game I have nothing to prove to you.
 
Old 07-22-2003, 07:50 AM   #10
dmcgrath
Pancake Tester
 
dmcgrath's Avatar
Daniel McGrath
USA
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 1,553
I've got a better idea for you. I just came up with it and I am a freaking genius!!! (just kidding)

Take a scene, your favorite piece of the animation you are working on, but only three or four seconds worth.

Now go back and really nail that thing in. Put as much thought into making things work that you can. Act it out, seriously get up off your butt and move around. Try and see if the motions in your character match up to what you would do in real life. Don't worry if it's an alien movement, or a guy in plate mail. Worry about the lighting and rendering later, that is time consuming and can really bog down your thoughts, detracting from your animation.

Come back and post just a few seconds. No sound, jsut good timing and good movement.

Good Luck



-dan
__________________
"Don't worry about the world coming to an end today.
It's already tomorrow in Australia."
---- Charles Schultz


Low - Poly Batman in Maya

Tiamat - The World Dragon (Maquette)


Online Tutorial: Character Rigging for Maya


 
Old 07-22-2003, 05:21 PM   #11
dgarrison
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 9
Brick Wall

Right.......................................ok then

Well at this point I can see I am wasting my time with you. I say ENOUGH so that we could move on from all of this, comment on the fact that I thought YOU WERE RIGHT about paying attention to everything when making a scene. Tell you that you did help me out, ask you to show me some of your work so that "I COULD LEARN" and what do you do.....................

You go right back to bashing me again and now think that I'm playing games with you..... are you an idiot?????

At this point I don't care what you do, who you work for, or what ever else you have to say. I'm not going to listen to someone that can't understand the concept of simple communication. Remember what i said about reading what people are saying before you react, you need to work on that badly man.

I will still end this on a positive note, good luck with your life, and career, and may all your dreams come true.........peace

Dave
__________________
www.sillyshports.com/dgarrison
garrison.dave@verizon.net
 
Old 07-22-2003, 05:28 PM   #12
dgarrison
New Member
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 9
Hey Dmcgrath

Hows it going,
thanks for the advice about what to do. As it stands now, I am currently creating my first poly character and am going to use it for my first animation in maya so I will probably do what you said only with the new character. Use it as a full learning experience.

You were right, I should have just let it all go from the beginning, o well i guess i learned something else right hehehehe. Anyway so I will let you know when i re-post the next animation so that you can see ok. take care and talk with you later

Dave
__________________
www.sillyshports.com/dgarrison
garrison.dave@verizon.net
 
Old 07-22-2003, 09:25 PM   #13
dmcgrath
Pancake Tester
 
dmcgrath's Avatar
Daniel McGrath
USA
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 1,553
Re: Hey Dmcgrath

Quote:
Originally posted by dgarrison

You were right, I should have just let it all go from the beginning, o well i guess i learned something else right hehehehe.



Indeed you have, my friend. It becomes an exercise in futility from the very beginning.



On the other hand, you can say you have finished an entire story from it's conception. That is something that many people never do. I am tackling that right now, also by myself.

I too will hopefully have something to show soon.

-dan
__________________
"Don't worry about the world coming to an end today.
It's already tomorrow in Australia."
---- Charles Schultz


Low - Poly Batman in Maya

Tiamat - The World Dragon (Maquette)


Online Tutorial: Character Rigging for Maya


 
Old 07-22-2003, 10:41 PM   #14
Rhid1en
Frequenter
 
Rhid1en's Avatar
Bryan Thomas
Turn Ten Studios
USA
 
Join Date: Mar 2002
Posts: 190
Send a message via ICQ to Rhid1en
A couple of quick thoughts, while waiting for my rendering to finish... hehe... anyway, before going back and taking the time to create more characters to add in at the end I would try cleaning up some of the animations in which you've already gotten started, especially since you're working on this in relatively scarce time trying to land a job with it. I agree, lighting and new textures would help out a lot, but as for animation.... first off, since they've both got cartoon characteristics, I would first work on exaggerating their movements a lot more. Make them more dramatic.. How are you creating the lip sync animation, morph's or bones? I would seriously work on creating more expressions for the characters and really push their facial movement first and foremost. A lot could be added to their body language as well. Right now the knight seems very ridged and stiff, maybe you were going for this because of the armor, but I would try stylizing it more if I were you. Keep in mind the character and his traits. He's arrogant and a no it all, or at least thinks he is, really he's kind of a silly clumsy character. Make him have more of a swagger in his walk cycle, perhaps trying to strut a little, but then stumble as he approaches the dummy. I think it's a really good start, now if you really want to break it in a tough industry, you need to really push it. Most important in telling this story as an animator, imagine it with no voiceovers and still being able to give these characters their personalities telling the story merely thru their body language and facial expressions... then when you add the sound to it, it will really come alive... keep at it, I know it can be tedious, but you've got a great start on things, now just polish her up!
Oh and DOMINICHI that's hardly a helpful critique... dgarrison as an artist, there will always be people to criticize; sometimes you learn from them, sometimes you just have to ignor their coments
 
Old 07-23-2003, 12:21 AM   #15
Ex Tessera
Veteran
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 80
Send a message via AIM to Ex Tessera
While I agree that some of the criticism wasn't helpful, I can't say I disagree with it.

I'm not going to focus on the modeling or lighting, becuase that wasn't the point of the piece.

The animation wasn't very good. Besides techincal problems like his knees popping all the time, he swings his arms around a ton, for seemingly no real reason, while holding a heavy sword and shield. The sound is also way off, it actually looks better without the sound on. The acting doesn't go with the audio very well.

I'd suggest doing a shorter animation, maybe a 10 second thing, and just refine the animation as much as you can. A kickass 10 second animation will be appreciated about a million times more than 3 minutes, that, well, isn't very fun to watch.

If this seems mean, I tried to keep the criticism as constructive as I could, and remember this is the focused critiques section.
__________________
I never apologize. I'm sorry, but it's just the way I am.
 
Thread Closed share thread


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
CGSociety
Society of Digital Artists
www.cgsociety.org

Powered by vBulletin
Copyright 2000 - 2006,
Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Minimize Ads
Forum Jump
Miscellaneous

All times are GMT. The time now is 09:32 AM.


Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.