Is Mixamo really somthing someone should rely on for rigging and skin weighting?

Become a member of the CGSociety

Connect, Share, and Learn with our Large Growing CG Art Community. It's Free!

THREAD CLOSED
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 06 June 2013   #1
Is Mixamo really somthing someone should rely on for rigging and skin weighting?

I have a friend and class mate who went on for the better half of an hour about how great Mixamo's auto rigger was. He was saying things like, "learning how to do it yourself is pointless because this is going to be used by everyone in the next 5 years." Which I immediately thought was dumb because it appears to only work for bipeds and a beta for quadruped, and nothing for anything with wings or say an alien biped whose legs function like birds and not humans.

My question really is, Is there any truth to what my friend is saying? I mean I'm not going to pass on learning to rig correctly because I'm sure Mixamo's computers were programmed to rig like a rigger would, but is this something most studios are using now?
 
Old 06 June 2013   #2
Originally Posted by RaptorCWS: I have a friend and class mate who went on for the better half of an hour about how great Mixamo's auto rigger was. He was saying things like, "learning how to do it yourself is pointless because this is going to be used by everyone in the next 5 years." Which I immediately thought was dumb because it appears to only work for bipeds and a beta for quadruped, and nothing for anything with wings or say an alien biped whose legs function like birds and not humans.

My question really is, Is there any truth to what my friend is saying? I mean I'm not going to pass on learning to rig correctly because I'm sure Mixamo's computers were programmed to rig like a rigger would, but is this something most studios are using now?


i know of no major or minor studios using mixamo. but i'm sure some people with very limited requirements are putting it to good use.

and regardless of if you could use mixamo or not and if you actually would use any rigging skills you pick up, learning at least a bit about it would probably benefit your understanding of 3d in general.
 
Old 06 June 2013   #3
generating a biped rig and assigning aproximate weights to it is easiest task in rigging. The real work begins in details - deformation fine tuning, facial setup, props, adaptation to animator or pipeline needs, rework ("we've got a new mesh for this", "this is gonna be a hood now"), tweaking ("that cheek appears flat when I do this and this"). A lot that's being done manually today in CG can be automated, yes, but fully automatically... it's gonna be a long wait. There are face mesh generators - do you see modellers/sculptors dissapearing left and right?
__________________
Victor
ngskintools.com - skinning plugin for Autodesk Maya
 
Old 06 June 2013   #4
the above post made it sound like i was saying you should learn mixamo... i meant you should learn a bit about rigging...
although you might be able to learn something about rigging by reverse engineering a mixamo rig, who knows...
 
Old 06 June 2013   #5
Your friend and class mate should start learning how to rig by himself, because this mixamo auto rigger will never take our jobs. I watched a couple of video about it, and it looks like a very basic rig, maybe it's ok for video games. What if you want a cartoon character, with bendy limbs and volume preservation ? What if your character has 3 arms, 1 tail, 5 tentacles, 2 antenna and a hood ? What if you need a very realistic rig wich will requires some correctives shapes and maybe even muscles ? And what about facial rig ?
No, seriously, this doesn't look like an awesome tool that will be used by everyone in 5 years. Autoriggers are good, but if you want to have a perfect rig, you'll always have to work on the details, as uiron says (by the way, your skintool is awesome dude, I could click on the relax button all day long)

If it is an autorigger you want, just go here : http://www.creativecrash.com/ and you'll probably find a lot of better ones, some of them are even free
 
Old 06 June 2013   #6
Thanks everybody. I'm more of a modeler myself and I personally do have issues with rigging my own models, but that's because im still learning retopology. I wanted to know more informed opinions before I said anything to him about what he was saying was wrong. I even said what happens if you have something with an odd number of legs and he just ignored it.
I'm not looking for an auto rigger myself. but I wouldnt mind learning some .mel script to make some simpler rigging tools to speed things up. I've always been a fan of learning new skill sets.
 
Old 06 June 2013   #7
I really like Mixamo's concept and they've provided convenient tools at affordable pricing for startups or individuals.

On another hand, I think what your friend said about rigging may be offending but there's some truths in that - it totally depends on the needs of the people. He's not into rigging, so he doesn't feel it's important to learn the process, which is fine. We can say the same thing to people who are not into modeling as well, ie., "learning how to do a human model from scratch is pointless because we are all working off templates anyway".
__________________
CGMovement:
http://CGMovement.com
 
Old 06 June 2013   #8
If you're fine with rubbery game res looking characters it's great!
__________________
blah blah blah
 
Old 06 June 2013   #9
Howdy,
Originally Posted by RaptorCWS: ...I wanted to know more informed opinions before I said anything to him about what he was saying was wrong...

Well, I wouldn't bother with arguing about it. Because even if you have enough evidence to prove him wrong and he concedes, remember the old saying, "Those convinced against their will are of the same opinion still."

Adios,
Cactus Dan
Edit:
P.S. When they invent the "Create great character animation from direct link to brain" button, then we'll all be out of a job.
__________________
It doesn't matter what people say about you, just as long as they're talking about you.

cactus3d.com, cactus3d-Plugins, CD Character Plugins forum
 
Old 06 June 2013   #10
Thread automatically closed

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.
__________________
CGTalk Policy/Legalities
Note that as CGTalk Members, you agree to the terms and conditions of using this website.
 
Thread Closed share thread



Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
CGSociety
Society of Digital Artists
www.cgsociety.org

Powered by vBulletin
Copyright 2000 - 2006,
Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Minimize Ads
Forum Jump
Miscellaneous

All times are GMT. The time now is 08:54 PM.


Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.