# Sharp edges on round surfaces

 02 February 2018 mauspat portfolio Patrick Maus Recklinghausen, Germany Sharp edges on round surfaces Hello everyone! I know this may be absolutely basic to a lot of you, but it's a problem that has been bothering me for way too long now and I'm still not able to decently fix this issue. I've been in a lot of situations where I wanted to have a rectangular shape with sharp edges (like an extrusion or cut-out) on a smooth or round surface. I have prepared a really basic example here: Now if I want the inwards-extruded area to have very sharp edges, I can add loop cuts to the sides of the shape. Then the shape will have sharp edges, however, there wll also be edges going across the whole object, which I obviously don't want. Then I could extract the extruded faces and add edges to them. Then the extruded area will be nice and sharp and the rest of the object will stay smooth, but then the edges will cut into the middle part. I could fix this by adding edge loops to the area that has been cut-out, but this would take me back to the previous problem - I would get those sharp edges on the smooth surface. I could also use the move tool and set it to "normals" and move the points that are not close to the sharp area away from each other, but I found that that doesn't really solve the problem either. It minimizes the sharp edges, but it's still not a very clean solution. So how do you guys deal with this problem? How do you create sharp edges on smooth surfaces without getting those nasty edges spanning across the entire surface? Thank you so much in advance for your advice, I've been struggling with this for so long now. -pat edit: I'm sorry, I wanted to post this into the modeling-forum and opened the wrong tab Last edited by mauspat : 02 February 2018 at 09:01 PM. Reason: posted in wrong forum share quote
 02 February 2018 Psyk0 Freelance chacha teacher   portfolio Patrick Boisvert 3D / 2D Artist Soldak Entertainment Quebec, Canada You need to start with a sphere that has more density and cut your details, then throw on a subdivision (or more depending on desired tightness). A denser mesh will support finer details, thus sharper edges. Sphere 1. (top left) is a dense sphere with shape cut (the square shape edges have been beveled inwards for visual interest) Sphere 2. (top right) has the same density but the contour of the square shape has support edges to make the border sharp. Sphere 3. Has the same polygon count as sphere 1, except the density is distributed in a different manner and results in tighter border This version could benefit from a support edge and keep relatively the same polycount and have tighter contour. Sphere 4. How tight / high are you ready to go? Most of these require very little manipulation, everything is done through the use of smoothing groups (hard edges in maya?) and stacking subdivision modifiers on top. __________________ Psyk03D share quote

 Posting Rules You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts vB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is Off CGSociety Society of Digital Artists www.cgsociety.org Powered by vBulletinCopyright ©2000 - 2006, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Forum Jump
 Please select one User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home -------------------- Gallery     Latest Entries     Featured 2D     Featured 3D     CG Awards     Community Awards Main     News     General Discussion     Off Topic     Recruitment         Temp Job Board Challenges     CGS Environment 101     Education     Demo Reel     Portfolio Review GROUPS WIP ADVICE     CGS Pro     Art Direction and Interviews     New 2D/3D Sketchbooks 2018     WIP 2D/3D & Animation         WIP/Critique: 3D         WIP/Critique: 2D             Speedpaints & Sketchbooks         WIP/Critique: Animation     Partners and Groups         Kitbash 3D Thunderdome         Collaborative Projects Autodesk     Autodesk Maya         Maya Dynamics         Maya Rendering         Maya Character Setup         Maya Programming     Autodesk Miscellaneous         Autodesk MotionBuilder         Autodesk Mudbox         Autodesk Softimage             XSI: Programming             ICE: Interactive Creative Environment     Autodesk 3ds max         3dsMax Tutorials & Tips         3dsMax Resources         3dsMax SDK and MaxScript         Plugins & Add-ons         Particle Flow     Mudbox Featured Gallery ZBrush     Featured Zbrush Gallery     Pixologic ZBrush     Keyshot     Marvelous Designer Texturing     Allegorithmic Substance         Substance Designer         Substance Painter         Substance Featured Gallery     Texturing XYZ     Mari     Marmoset Toolbag Software     Maxon Cinema 4D         Cinema 4D Resources     Side Effects Houdini     Compositing Software         The Foundry Nuke         Adobe After Effects         Autodesk Effects and Compositing         Eyeon Software Digital Fusion     Additional Software         Lightwave 3D             LW Resources             LW Tutorials         The Foundry Modo             The Foundry Time Travel Challenge         E-on Software Vue         Photoshop / Painter         Blender         3DCoat Techniques     Art Techniques and Theories     Digital Matte Painting         Digital Matte Painting Mini-Challenge     Modeling         Modeling Challenge             Member Model Collection     Texturing and Surfacing     Character Rigging     Animation     Lighting and Shaders         Lighting Challenges     Compositing and Editing     Anatomy and Figurative Art         SPOTLIGHT: Best of the Artistic Anatomy and Figurative Art Forum         Tutorials and Workshops         Personal Anatomy & Sketchbook Threads         References, Resources, and Supplies Technical     VR/AR     Master Virtual Reality with BrioVR     Workstation Builds     Game Engine     Graphics Programming     Technical and Hardware CGS Labs     Sketchbooks     Hardcore Crit     Discussions and Meet Ups
Miscellaneous

All times are GMT. The time now is 03:44 PM.