Maya group

Become a member of the CGSociety

Connect, Share, and Learn with our Large Growing CG Art Community. It's Free!

THREAD CLOSED
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
Old 12 December 2012   #1
Maya group

Why in maya a group is not a group like in 3dmax, in which when you make a group yo are not afraid to move it clicking anywhere?
 
Old 12 December 2012   #2
No idea what you mean by 'afraid to move it clicking anywhere'.

But to answer your original question:

Q: "Why in maya a group is not a group like in 3dmax"

A: "Because Maya is not 3dsmax"


Seriously. That's the answer.
But to seem less condescending, I will point out the fact that 'groups' in Maya are nothing more than empty Transform nodes, and by 'empty' we mean devoid of a Shape node and thus of any geometry of its own. That's why you can move a group, because it's a Transform, and has transformation information (move rotate scale) that applies to itself and any of its children as is expected of a DAG node.
 
Old 12 December 2012   #3
In maya you can use one thing in several different purposes. It is very intellectually designed. That is why those guys switching from 3DS Max become confused. A group is an unseen object. That is necessary in rigging works too. The same thing you can use in grouping purposes of your objects. It can be used for group transformation too. May be it will help.
 
Old 01 January 2013   #4
I'm not familiar enough with Max to know what groups are like.. are they more like sets in maya? With sets you can have a hierarchy of selectable collections of nodes. You can sort of do this with groups as well .. you just need to turn off inherit transforms on all the child nodes
__________________
blah blah blah
 
Old 01 January 2013   #5
I have very minor experience from 3dsmax, but from what I recall groups there have two states, open and closed (and defaults to closed). If you click an item on a closed group it selects the entire group. In maya a group is always open, and when you click an object belonging to a group you select the object. You can select the group by either using the outliner and select the group (you can trust them to move together, when you are in fact moving the group), or select an object and press the up-arrow to move selection up in the hierarchy (there are probably lots of other ways as well, but these are the ones I'm using).
 
Old 01 January 2013   #6
I too know little about groups in Max, but I assume it is safe to say the following:

if you are planning to dedicate yourself to Maya, you should assume nothing works exactly the same as in Max, even if something should share a similar name. The Modifier Stack bears a striking resemblance to Maya's DG hierarchy (construction history), but they work differently. Add a polySplit node after a polyCube node, then change the number of divisions on the polyCube node and you'll see why (hint: vertex IDs changed upstream and effect the nodes expected input downstream).
A good example are groups. In Maya, you should think of less of 'grouping objects', even though that is a common phrase used in Maya 'lingo'. Instead, think of it as a Parent-Child Relationship. That's exactly what it is.
Grouping a set of objects is nothing more than making them children of a single Parent node.
Children in Maya are like biological offspring (hence the name): They inherit certain properties from their parents.
In Maya, transform nodes that are made children of another transform node inherit the parent transform's transformation, i.e. translation, rotation and scale, unless explicitly set to not do so via their "Inherits Transform" attribute.
That is why you'll notice that an object's transform information, as displayed in the channelbox, suddenly changes when you parent it under some other object (unless the new parent happens to sit at the origin and have no rotation applied to it). This is because the (now child) object's parent space has switched from Worldspace to whatever its new parent object's space is. And Maya, by default when parenting, tries not to modify the child object's transformation. It does this by calculating the transformation in the new parent space that has to be applied to the child so that its transformation appears the same as before it was parented ( think of it as the difference between the relation of the new parentspace to the old parentspace, which might have been worldspace, or some other object's local space).

A thing to note: when you group a set of objects, i.e. parent them under some parent node, and select the parent node, the children will appear highlighted in the viewport. Initially, it may appear that the children, too, are selected. But they're not. It's simply Maya telling you that those children are affected (in this case: their transformations) by the parent.

Hope this helps clarify the issue a bit.

Last edited by Nyro : 01 January 2013 at 02:53 PM.
 
Old 01 January 2013   #7
Nyro, thanks for your explanation. It suffice my question. But I didnt say that maya was 3dsmax but asked why it doesnt behave "like" in 3dsmax. I have been using maya for a long time now and havent used max since 8 years. But sometimes I wonder why something is the way it is. Now your answer explain everything beautifully. It is more of a parenting and less than a group in the sense of a group as i was accustomed in max.
 
Old 01 January 2013   #8
so..... in Max groups are more like selection sets in Maya?
__________________
blah blah blah
 
Old 01 January 2013   #9
No. There are Selection Sets in Max as well.

This discussion led me to peruse the Max documentation. It turns out that...

  • ... a Group in Max is very similar to a Group in Maya; it has its own transforms, and any children of the group inherit this transformation. It can be animated etc.
  • ... a group can have its own modifier stack. Modifiers are inherited by childrend, yet they retain their own modifiers. If a child is removed from the Group, it inherits an instance of the group's modifiers.
  • ... A closed group only allows selection and modification of the group as a whole, not its invidivual children.
  • ... Vice versa, an open group allows access to and modification of individual children on a temporary basis (until the group is closed again).
  • ... Groups are hierarchical: they can contain other groups, which themselves can contain groups, etc.

So, in essence, a Group in 3dsMax is a way of creating a parent-child relationship just like in Maya.
Now I have to question the OP's initial post: if my understanding of a Group in 3ds is correct, it would behave much the same as in Maya: selecting it would make it possible to move it too. So where was your problem in the first place?
 
Old 07 July 2013   #10
maya double transforms and instances

1 agree max groups and instancing is way better than maya, loft a surface, extrude a pipe
and group with a poly model, to move all the components you have to turn off inherit transforms on the nurb surfaces to avoid double transformation.

now instance that group and it wont transform the instance of the surface because inherit transform is off.

This sums up mayas current problem why it can never be like Houdini, max , cinema4d or
solid works or catia its node structure is a mess.

if you want to see the current state of maya look inside its node editor its chaos.
 
Old 07 July 2013   #11
Quote: This sums up mayas current problem why it can never be like Houdini, max , cinema4d or
solid works or catia its node structure is a mess.

if you want to see the current state of maya look inside its node editor its chaos.


That's an absurd comment and opinion, but thanks for sharing! I never really thought those other applications handled node editing well at all, especially not Max or C4D. It's nice to feel wrong about something, once in awhile.

I really don't see how Maya's "group" function could be any easier to work with.
__________________
Commodore 64 @ 1MHz
64KB RAM
1541 Floppy Drive


"Like stone we battle the wind... Beat down and strangle the rains..."
 
Old 07 July 2013   #12
maya groups instances and double transforms

I think vancliff had a fair comment.

I am not saying certain programs are better than others,
But if you say build a car from nurbs curves, make surfaces with those curves, group all the curves and surfaces together, in maya you have to turn off inherit transform to move the surfaces in the group with the group.

this is similar to other 3d programs.

However when I instance the group and move the new group the surfaces inside the new group do not follow the group, in other 3d programs they do.

if anyone can suggest a tutorial or link that solves this it would be helpful.
 
Old 07 July 2013   #13
Instancing, in this case, only applies to shape nodes and their transforms. Since Groups have no shape node, the instancing gets messy. For example, if you instance a bunch of groups around (say, flowers or trees grouped together), then go to select one instance, it will select them all.

This has to do with the parent/child relationship itself, not really with instancing directly.
__________________
Commodore 64 @ 1MHz
64KB RAM
1541 Floppy Drive


"Like stone we battle the wind... Beat down and strangle the rains..."
 
Old 07 July 2013   #14
instance of a group

this link shows the instance of a group and what happens when you move the instance, the surfaces in purple
are left behind,
http://www.flickr.com/photos/93465359@N03/9244439702/
 
Old 07 July 2013   #15
Maya groups delete all children,,,.. unlike in Max. In Maya I have to ungroup everything and re-order all, but in Max I can delete and arrange anything the way I want. And, yes,.. Max's grouping is sooo much better.
This goes for bones too. I can select a bone in Max without it 'highlighting' everything beneath.. and this (sorry Maya) is a huge rigging issue for just selecting bones. And still is.
Lots and lots of time I have wasted doing this in Maya,.. not to mention the namespace issue. That should be set up like 3dsMax's (is it Maxs'?) as well.
... I've submitted info to Autodesk, and earlier Maya/ Wavefront over the years for all of this.
 
Thread Closed share thread



Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
CGSociety
Society of Digital Artists
www.cgsociety.org

Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2006,
Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Minimize Ads
Forum Jump
Miscellaneous

All times are GMT. The time now is 08:59 AM.


Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.