|12-26-2007, 03:18 PM||#46|
Bude, United Kingdom
Join Date: Nov 2007
Firstly let me say that this is awsome, staggeringly detailed and beautiful.
But I still have some small crits.
In your impressive hi-res picture i can see parts which dont look as high quality as others, for instance, at the lower left hand corner, the trees and grass have a pc game look about them, i'm pretty sure i can see textures strected over planes in there.
Some of the ropes holding the bridge look like candy sticks to me and the ridges in the rope are exadurated.
The waterfalls at the bottom right don't look as real as the water effects further away, and the water coming out of the pipes, at the highest resolution look like steam. I know water turns to vapour sometimes when it falls but yours looks like its vapour/fully-turbulent coming out of the pipes IMO.
There is a badly places tee over the windmill, i cant tell whether its in the background or physically growing off the windmill in the foreground. Obviously its the former, but still, it played tricks on my eyes.
Some of the rocks at the very bottom have an overly CG look about them, maybe the textures are a bit streched, its a tiny crit.
Sheep dont look that wooly at hi-res. Horses legs look a bit strange.
I'm really having to look hard to find problems. When you get brilliant work you get hard crit.
Awsoem stuff anyway!
|12-26-2007, 03:43 PM||#47|
Join Date: Jun 2004
Excellent work! The details and concept are amazing, however I still have some critics:
Overall I think that increasing the contrast migh improve the impression. Also, I find the background more cut off than necessary, looks a bit unnaturally to me.
I also agree with some stuff written above - the waterfalls, rope etc.
However, as said before, really wonderul piece!!!
|12-26-2007, 04:21 PM||#48|
Washington DC, USA
|12-26-2007, 04:42 PM||#49|
Join Date: Aug 2005
HUGE! Not my cup of tea but something that really surprised me. Man, how can you keep working on such a complex scenes? Great Job! 5*, congrats for plug and I believe in award for this!
|12-26-2007, 08:28 PM||#55|
Character Designer / 3D Artist
IlusionDigital Art Studio
Join Date: Mar 2005
Mamma mia!! What an impressive image!! i really love the contrast between the futuristic city and the poor village
Congrats and my vote for an award
|12-26-2007, 08:35 PM||#56|
Chris Campbell Chris Campbell
San Francisco, USA
Join Date: Sep 2005
omg i cant even finish a small projects thats absolutly insane bro... O M G! lol.. keep up the great work idk how you got so much detail int here man do you by chance have a work time estimate? lol... g r R E A T !
|Thread Closed share thread|
|Thread Tools||Search this Thread|