View Full Version : Different MultiPlane input size breaks tracking

08 August 2007, 10:31 PM
I am exporting a 3D sequence for use in a Shake composite. The 3D movie is loaded into Shake and is 800x600. I then create a MultiPlane node and load in my Maya Ascii camera data, which loads in fine. I attach a backdrop image of 1024x768 to this node.

Then I use an over node to put the foreground 3D movie on top of the backdrop. The backdrop moves and changes perspective but it slides around a bit under the 3D movie. After a lot of messing around with my camera data, I try making the backdrop the same size as the 3D movie and the tracking works fine - the 3D elements in the rendered movie align with the background.

Now this is not a huge problem because even for bigger backdrops, all I do is use a viewport node and the tracking works without cropping out the image or downsizing. However I'm still wondering why this is the case because on p497 of the Shake 4.1 manual, it shows a bunch of images connected to MultiPlane nodes and they don't look the same size nor do they need viewport nodes. I don't understand how the image size would affect the tracking anyway.

I don't think it's a MultiPlane setting because in the manual they have different sized inputs going into the same node.

On a side note, does anyone know how to stop the transform handles in the viewer from scaling? When an object gets really large or small, the rotate handles practically take up the entire viewer or almost disappear, which is ridiculous. There has to be a way to keep them at a fixed size. The handles should stay at about 50% of the size of the viewer window at all times IMO.

09 September 2007, 11:15 PM
I notice that changing the clip layer affects the tracking too. That doesn't seem right. I would have thought the clip size would only affect cropping, it shouldn't adjust them so as to change the tracking. If I go to all the bother of aligning and matching layers and then I decide to change the output resolution, I shouldn't have to start all over again.

Like say I have 3 layers, one is 800x600, another is 1024x768 and a 3rd is 1280x1024. If I clip to layer 1 and the tracking all works, changing the cropping to layer 2 or 3 shouldn't change that in the same way that if I used an over node and change the clipping mode, it doesn't alter what happens with each layer relative to the other.

CGTalk Moderation
09 September 2007, 11:15 PM
This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.