View Full Version : A medieval image for your Critique ...

05 May 2006, 02:45 PM
Hello everyone,

I recently completed a medieval/fantasy image and would love to have your critique on it. Here it is:

People do ask about the process, so I'll just go ahead and describe it here.

STEP 1: I drew the contours in pencil, and then with a Sharpie pen. Scanned them in at 91 dpi with the aspect ratio of the web browser window. :

STEP 2: I then used GIMP to color it with flat shades using the magic wand. I put them on separate layers. I got this:

STEP 3: I scaled up and blurred the sillouettes of the characters to make the character shadows and put them on a third layer. The shadow color was the background color with its value darkened down.

STEP 4: The shadow from the ball was from a radial gradient tool. I put that on a fifth layer.

STEP 4: I flattened the image and got the above result.

Some Questions and Issues

[1] I worked in TIFF, but the above final result is in JPG. You can see circular bands centerd around the crystal ball. I tried saving in JPG with no compression (max quality), I tried saving in PNG with no compression, but still got them. They are not in the TIFF image. Is there any way I can save the picture as JPG or PNG (pics will be on website) without those bands ?

[2] If a professional artist was commissioned to do something like this, what process would he follow ? How long would it take him/her? The above process took me a long time because I had a hard time getting the colors and shadows to get along with one another. Also, drawing human figures is not easy for me.

Thanks for your input !


05 May 2006, 03:40 PM
The girl - is she an elf/dwarf? She seems small in comparison to the others.

The circular bands you're talking about -- I can't really tell they're there, it doesn't seem to harm the picture.

My only suggestion would be to apply more shading, to distinguish the slightly-shaded with the heavily-shaded, also put highlights near the ball.

Good luck with it :)

CGTalk Moderation
05 May 2006, 03:40 PM
This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.