The Treehouse, JIm Maxwell (2D)

[Ngon]

i like the perspecitve and the rendering style.

[Vinnieart]

This is really amazing, nice work!

[Vinta]

:eek: :eek: Great work :eek: :eek:

[Intervain]

really beautiful image!:thumbsup:

[JohanWendesten]

This is super awsome actually.

[adrephil]

Excellent!...the detail is amazing:thumbsup:

Karisa:)

[Harmonic]

Agreed, everything about this is fantastic!

[kiboSVK]

niiice work I like a palette and light very good work 4*:thumbsup:

[griffinart]

very nice style .... :thumbsup:

[Daffydd]

Love it! Very nicely done!

Daf

[O'Connor]

Hey Jim,

I think the concept looks great! I only have one small criticism. The shadows on the wheels of the wagon seem a bit too strong. All the other shadows in the scene have a much softer edge. I do really like all those tree houses and the colours are beautiful! Keep up the great work!

Ciarán

[reviresco]

Wow, thanks guys for the kind comments guys! I enjoyed working on this piece and will post a new one soon. Ciaran, thanks for the critique...I know what you mean about the wheel, looking forward to seeing your work posted here!

[vasishtr]

Awesome work Jim :thumbsup: . I love the colours, specially the grass and the sky. and of course, the dog. 1 comment, if I may...I feel the box and the pieces of wood on the wagon are too perfect...Just nitpicking..

[reviresco]

Thanks Vasisht, I like nitpicking, usually helps me see something I haven't noticed...I agree there's a cleanness about the boxes and wagon, I'm sure I could paint it up a little more...

cheers

Jim

[O'Connor]

Congratulations on the CG Choice Award Jim! Well deserved. I look forward to seeing more of your work!

[NatriX]

What I really love about this piece is the slightly surreal atmosphere created of the lightening, the perspective and the beautiful sky. To me that really makes it look like a childhood memory, or a dream you can remember. Did you consider anything like this while painting or is that just coincidental or my impression?

Anyway, masterfully done!

[reviresco]

thanks for your comments and critiques,

NatriX, yeah I did purposely want it to have a dream-like quality, it's based on a memory from when I was around 8 years old - when you try to visualize those things, they tend to 'look' a little hazy...originally I wanted the sky to look more morning-like light blues and salmon sort of tones in the sky...but the blown out quality of the light and the clouds seemed to fit best

cheers

[Jeffparadox]

couldnt help replying... this is the one of the best compositions i've seen in a while. the line from top left to bottom right carries the eye perfectly. beautiful placement of elements. composition makes you ignore the weaknesses of the image, which are very little...

[flaviomonteiro]

It´s 2d with 3d?
Nice job, I´d like to know how it was done.

[penball]

what is the light behind the wood which is on the the vihicle? sun?

[aphextweak]

Wow, your image made me feel like I was a young boy again. Makes me want to go back in time an play in a tree house like that. Beautiful rendering of a childhood memory. Congrats of the front page. Thanks for sharing.

[superputing]

You really impressed me by your brushwork!

[knaidu1977]

good work! reminds me of childhood days as well:)

[Blaschke]

strange render but i like it.

[charlesDESIGN]

Very nice!

[ethnobot]

Excellent Work! Inspirational indeed.
Thanks and keep it up!

Best,
ethnobot

[Shramir]

if this is from an actual memory of yours then you had to be the luckiest kid alive

=)

[levent]

:buttrock:very nice job

[Lua]

beautiful. =]
can't find a single criticism, excellent work.

[nightwoodwolf]

cool stuff :thumbsup:

[Designer CS]

great work great coloring but lighting on the heat of childern needs to be adjusted

[dorkabilly]

This is a great piece. I love the mood and the perspective of the shot...good work

[CGTalk Moderation]

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.