Compositing Reel

[homer4lyfe]

Not bad dude. I think the first piece with the waterfall was the best, very well done. The New York shot the lighting on the flying cars looked just a bit off, they didnt match quite as well as the other elements. I think the weakest element was the beach ball in the beach shot. The animation on the ball was not quite natural enough and the lighting was too diffuse. The ball needed a little reflection or specularity around the edges to help it look more like rubbery plastic. Overall though its pretty good stuff. Always fun to see Comp reels.

[wesleygh]

I think the weakest element was the beach ball in the beach shot.

Thanks for the critique. The beach ball shot was only really meant to show camera tracking so I didn't spend too much time on actual color correction etc. Thanks for the critique, and I will definitely go into the city shot and look at those car colors again.

[Radiospank]

i thought it was great... amazing

[CGTalk Moderation]

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.