green guardian, ameen nakasewee (2D)

[Ishtar]

Very good picture, the armor, body are beautiful !
The gate is really original, well it's very good job !
Cheer :thumbsup:

[hasanaliakhtar]

Excellent job on that gate..Loved the lighting and ur pallette there..Simply fantastic..One thing more I really liked the perspective there and the angle to present that artwork..Really nice war feel of the image..Take carez..All the best..4****..Cheers:)

[MojtabaN]

Yes it`s great very nice work
and very GRANDEUR
Cheers..:thumbsup::buttrock:

[Samuraikuroi]

Sawatdi krap Ameen. Very good colours, light and perspective. KICK ASS!

[Dianae]

Excellent work, great perspective, textures and use of colours, very well done!
5 stars :)

[waheednasir]

Excellent work, great perspective, textures and use of colours, very well done!
5 stars :)

agree...:).

very good work...:thumbsup:.

[Viking-Heart]

wow, excellent piece. Really good. Some things I think could be improved: He's left biceps look, I don't know... unnaturally big.. especially the upper part. Also, I think the handle of the sword and the blade have different perspectives, which makes it a little odd.
Then something non-technical. You mention he's a giant.. well... I'd never realised if you didn't tell me. You could put in something (can be very subtle... doesn't need to change your composition) for comparison purposes. Cause I don't see anything that tells me he's bigger than an actual human.
Again, fantastic job. Keep posting, please. (:

[rubenmontecinos]

I like the image. excellent view and color

[Aenvil]

Great job!

In regards to "Viking-Hearts (http://forums.cgsociety.org/member.php?u=250537)" comment about the bicep, I think if your having a problem with the proportion you could explain as to why, However, to have a bigger left arm could only result in swinging that ginormous ( it's a word now) sword around.

I do agree with the rest of what was said.

4 stars for me.

Cool

[Zodiac]

this picture is totally awesome. I loved it.

just for improvement,
I can only add small details. if you add some cool blue tint in the shadows, it will match with yellow lighting , break the monochrome composition and will strenghten the unwelcoming atmosphere effect.

and just a subjective opinion,
I understand that this is an ancient mood so everything is sand yellow, desaturated. but just to make the composition more flashy and interesting you can make one of the accessories on the giant unnaturally saturated. more alive.. this would give it more of a magical effect also will increase the contrast. just to make it more interesting.

[Wiry]

Wow. I really like this picture. The character is well posed and stylish. Colours work great too. I wouldn't pay too much attention to the critique about the character's anatomy. I mean, the guy is green and has glowing eyes! Complaining about physique is unreasonable here, especially when he looks so fine! Keep up the good work.

[Viking-Heart]

In regards to "Viking-Hearts (http://forums.cgsociety.org/member.php?u=250537)" comment about the bicep, I think if your having a problem with the proportion you could explain as to why, However, to have a bigger left arm could only result in swinging that ginormous ( it's a word now) sword around.
Cool

woh, dude.. take it easy.. :S I don't have any problem with the proportions... The guy asked for critique, and I was trying to be useful.
I didn't mean the left biceps was bigger than the right one (besides I can't actually see the right one)... What I was trying to say is that the muscles of the shoulder usually make a "straight" line along the biceps and the pecs. Especially when the arm is extended.
http://img119.imageshack.us/img119/3256/adobeid317asp8494457274bg0.jpg
http://img119.imageshack.us/img119/3575/adobeid164asp21003187tw2.jpg
In ameeba's illustration, the biceps looks almost above (relatively speaking) the shoulder. That's all.

and Wiry: With all respect, my opinion is as valid as anyone's; you can't go telling people not to listen to what I say. That's very unfair, don't you think? Mainly because I wasn't trying to put him down, I was trying to help. And hey, "Complaining about physique is unreasonable here, especially when he looks so fine!", THAT doesn't make much sense. Because it's fantasy you don't take anatomy serious?? It's obviously an anthropomorphic figure, you MUST consider anatomy... especially if ALL the rest of the body has a perfectly recognizable human anatomy.

We are all here to learn and improve, try to be more tolerant for people with different opinions. :hmm:

[boutiquecraft]

greate picture.:thumbsup:
i love that falchion!

[plasteredcat]

neat work here, and a good design for a character! Good stuff:thumbsup:

[Littlelizard]

Wow i love the character, nice colors too!:thumbsup:

[CrisdeLara2007]

Wowwwww.....Fantastic! greate piece...I loved the color choice...great!!

[Kalensir]

Impressive image, i like perspective and colors. :thumbsup:

[niva]

Didn't read earlier replies so someone else might have posted this. There is some loss of depth in the shoulder-chest-bicep tie-in area. You did great on the muscles though.

Also the hand holding the shield is too small, I understand you were trying to emphasise perspective and probably made it smaller on purpose but it's still too small given the angle of the rest of the painting.

Neat colors, good job really. As an illustration it looks great so I'm just picking on small details.

[ameeba]

thank you very much for all reply, every critique make me see my mistake:)

[Orbits]

Awesome!

I love the colors.

[CGTalk Moderation]

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.