The Great Forest, Moy Shin Hung (2D)

[EhsanD]

It's really great job ... Very nice ... :thumbsup:
I give you 4 stars ...
Cheers .

[ozhaver]

Beautiful!

The girl is hard to note because of her skintones. I like the fact that she blends but perhaps she is blending a lil bit too much; could be improve by adding more shadows too, she seems a bit flat.

As for the rest, simply magical. Love the perspective and the atmosphere of it. It really pulled me in, and that is rare for me to say.

4 stars too!

[inky2]

Very interesting work!

I can give only one advice-make first plan and girl on the swing more contrast ,a little dark.
Very nice:)

[dinfet]

looks great to me my only real gripe is the girls hand on the swing is a the same spot as the root of the tree crossing the river, a bit discrating...but that may only be me

[Nickillus]

Just beautiful Moy.
I bet this looks even more wonderful bigger.

Nick

[Jenya]

Very nice! I wish you could move the "camera" a bit closer to the girl to reveal more of the work youve done on the character and also to peek over her shoulder...in a sneaky way, ya know :) I think, there also a problem with the river. It catapults me violently out of the picture. Its only after 2 or 3 rounds, that I start to read whats going on in there... hope I made my point clear :)

I like it nonetheless.

[MichaelZHsee]

its great to see another country mate here,nice going with the overall mood.i'm with oz about the character on the swing~though she shouldnt strike out too much frm the scene,u could add alil more to differentiate the character from the background,just alil more would do.u've captured a very nice angle btw:)would love to see more from ya:thumbsup:u have my vote****

[Rysh]

hey Moysh!....what did you paint?...it is great...I very like perspectives like this!
:bounce:

[Rysh]

oh....atmosphere is realy great!:hmm:

[plasteredcat]

Beautiful textures and mood... I love the way everything comes together without being too obvious, really difficult to achieve sometimes, and you've master it in here. Brilliant...:thumbsup:

[Agata]

Impressive work. As much as the previous one.
Welcome! :)

[Moysh]

EhsanD: Thanks!

Oz-Haver: Thanks for your advice. I agreed for now the girl blend in to the same level as the whole painting. I intended so originally to draw more focus to the background instead. She should stand out a lil bit more to enchance the atmosphere.

inky2: Thanks.

dinfet: This is interesting. I don't exactly understand the distraction part though.

Nickillus: I actually feel quite uncomfortable for posting at this size, alot of details are missing.

Jenya: Haha. That is cute but useful nonetheless. I know what you mean. I think the reason why the river would disrupt the eye movement could be it is too contrast. If I were to fix this, I think I'd adjust so that the transition of the river would be further up, leaving only the very bright part to the top. Thanks for pointing this out.

MichaelZHsee: Hey mate! I agreed with what you both have said. By bringing out the contrast in the girl slightly, I believe the whole piece would have a different feel. It would speak more of "the girl IN the wood" rather than "the girl AND the wood".

Rysh, harachte, Agata: Thanks. :)

[jalingo]

Excellent illustration. I love the textures especially the ground cover and leaves (the bottom picture shows this).

[Spc]

Simply beautifull.
Exceptional work.
:applause:

[niva]

I really like this image - very deep and dark so it gets the feeling across. I think you should've used a bit more saturated color in some of the lighted areas and closer to the viewer to give it even more depth but that's nitpicking.


Great job!

[CGTalk Moderation]

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.