PDA

View Full Version : New Socket Types


chymera
03-09-2006, 08:59 AM
Hi guys, I just have a few questions.

1. Is AMD releasing a new socket type (replacing 939) anytime soon?

The reason is that I'm purchasing a new computer soon and am tossing up between a better motherboard (extra features) or a better cpu. I only do a little bit of graphics work, and I don't really multitask, so I don't think dual core is for me just yet. See, if I spend more on the motherboard now, and upgrade the CPU later, the motherboard will last me longer.
But if AMD replaces the 939 socket soon, there is little point in spending lots of money when they will be superseded. ( I realise this will be a neverending cycle, but if 939 is near the end of its life......)

2. Does anyone know of any RAM brands which have compatibility issues with the Asus SLI range of motherboards? ( I haven't quite figured which one to go with yet but the Deluxe looks nice) I can source 2GB of either Kingston or Geil RAM for under $300 AUS.

So far these are the specs I am leaning towards (it's primarily a gaming computer)


AMD Athlon 3700+ or an X2 4200+ (the 3700 should be fine for a while methinks)
Asus A8N-SLi (standard or deluxe, depending on the CPU choice, I'm on a budget,plus Sli for upgradeability, not just replacement of GPU)
2GB 3200 Kingston or Geil Value RAM
XFX or Leadtek (opinions on the Leadtek please) 7800gt
120GB Seagate 7200rpm HD

Ok, lotsa questions, any input is appreciated. I know most of you will push for the X2 won't ya :).
My budget is limited, so don't get too excited with the reccomendations :)

grrr... decisions

lots
03-09-2006, 01:59 PM
1) yes. AM2 is scheduled for launch very soon actually. If you are looking to the long term, it would be best to wait for this switch. However, keep in mind that this isn't really going to be bringing performance gains to the table at all. The only advance is the support for DDR2 on AM2 compatable chips. And because of the state of the tech (DDR2) AMD chips really do not gain much from the current incarnation of it. However, this new socket will be the base platform for coming dual core CPUs that have yet to be released, plus it generates the headroom needed (once DDR2 gets more advanced) for AMD's quad core CPUs due out sometime next year.

2) Most motherboard makers have a list of compatable RAM on thier website. I'm sure somewhere burried in Asus's site is a table with a list of modules that will work on that board. Though if you stick to major brands, such as Kingston, Corsair, OCZ, etc. I dont think you'll run into problems. Also careful with that Asus, the northbridge fan on that motherboard has a tendancy to die :)

Video card, I'd grab an eVGA... Good warranty and good price. Cheaper than both XFX and Leadtek, last I looked.

chymera
03-09-2006, 08:15 PM
thanks for the reply. Only problem is trying to find a stockist of evga here in Aus.

lots
03-09-2006, 10:34 PM
Well XFX and Leadtech aren't bad either. XFX has a double lifetime warranty, that will replace or service your card for as long as you own it. ANd if you sell it, it will cover the second owner as well.

chymera
03-10-2006, 08:27 AM
I'll be getting the pc in a few months so i will be waiting a bit anyway.

Once AM2 is released I will check prices and see what to do from there.

SweetDreamz
03-10-2006, 04:18 PM
If you want to wait just a little bit longer, wait till the Conroe comes out and check some benchmarks then. Previews look extremely promising, and they seem to have come up with a winner against AMD. This year may just be Intel's year.

MadMax
03-10-2006, 04:50 PM
If you want to wait just a little bit longer, wait till the Conroe comes out and check some benchmarks then. Previews look extremely promising, and they seem to have come up with a winner against AMD. This year may just be Intel's year.

Yes, if you consider that the Intel benchmarks are jacked up to look good, and not really relative to real performance.

If you overlook the heavy use of benchmarks that are extremely cache sensitive (with Conroe have 4mb cache)

And if you want to overlook the fact that they CLAIM they compared to an FX 60, vut in fact there is no way to prove this as theyt were using an outdated bios on the AMD system that didn;t report the type of CPU that was being used, only saying "unknown".

And if you overlook the fact that some of those AMD scores on some of those benchmarks were substantially higher in reviews on hardware sites than were shown here.

Conroe does appear to be quite the magical leap in progress, and vertainly appears to be a step in the right direction. However we have not seen benchmarks for AMD CPU's that are coming out in the same time frame as Conroe (Conroe being doubtful if it is before christmas)

No idea on how AMD will perform using DDR2 800

no idea what the new AMD memory controller is capable of

no idea how much the internal speed increase in the new AMD cores will effect the benchmarks.


Of course the question is, are you waiting almost a year to buy a computer. or do you need one soon?

Conroe is at least 6 months before it's paper launch. give it at least 3-4 months after than before you can actually buy one.

AMD will be available with their new AM2 products June 6th.

lots
03-10-2006, 04:51 PM
Thats at least 6 months away, baring any setbacks on Intel's side. If you need a machine soon (next couple of months) The AMD CPUs will be the best deal. if conroe was only a month or two away, I'd recommend waiting it out and checking benchmarks then, but seeing as it is not, might as well get the best you can get right now. And that is AMD.

lots
03-10-2006, 04:55 PM
Anand had a follow up article with updated BIOS and some corrections to thier testing. Here's the link: http://www.anandtech.com/tradeshows/showdoc.aspx?i=2716

SweetDreamz
03-10-2006, 05:45 PM
Looks like we have an AMD fan here...

And I didn't refer to any specific benchmark here. Don't know why you're so hyped up 'bout what I said.

The Conroe beating the FX-60 by 20% is quite a believable. Of course, some will say it's not fair to compare old tech vs new tech. But I'm not gonna argue, read enough of those threads already.

And the pricing of the Conroes look very competitive. Plus, it's about time Intel did something good, as you would expect them to do so since they have more resources. At least computer news would be abit more interesting this year compare to the last few years.

Also, AM2 with DDR2 won't bump up their performance too much.

Like I said earlier, we can only wait 'till it comes out to see if the benchmarks are true.

chymera
03-11-2006, 08:58 AM
I read somewhere, I'll try and find a link, that ddr2 doesn't increase performance with the AM2, which is why they didn't upgrade to ddr2 a while ago. They said that the relaxed timings cancelled out the higher frequency. I think it was just to move to the new generation of RAM.

It sucks that it is socket 940 but not opteron 940...... oh well, once the time comes I will make my decision. (its for my birthday at the end of june, my 18th)

I'll try and find a source for this.

AMD ftw methinks, but thats personal preference. I don't like some of Intel's decisions (regarding the lawsuit etc) if they are proven, I haven't been following it lately. It hasn't ended yet has it?

lukx
03-11-2006, 09:19 AM
I also want to get AMD platform soon and wasn't sure if to wait for am2 or get platform with 939 socet. After reading many articles about am2 I will get 939 now. There won't be any speed gain. It might only happen when ddr2 800mhz will come out. 939 with nforce chipsed is tested and proven to be good. I don't think that after am2 will come out, first mainboards will be out of box ready to handle quad cores so okey you will be abole to get am2 amd with fatser speeds but when quad will come out I think there will be also need to again change mobo. I don't remmeber in my histaory of building pcs to ever making upgrade with only buying only cpu. I was almoust always buying new mobo cpu and ram. So for me there is no point to wait. This is why next month I'm getting evga 7900 gtx, asus A8N-E, 2GB OCZ 3200, AMD 4400 X2, WD aptor 150 :)

tecton3d
03-11-2006, 01:27 PM
It might only happen when ddr2 800mhz will come out.

. . . DDR2 for servers may not be too far off:


"This one is a dual Socket F board called the KFN4-DRE, and the spec sheet has some goodies on it. It confirms the server based DDR2-800 . . ."

http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=30146

CGTalk Moderation
03-11-2006, 01:27 PM
This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.