PDA

View Full Version : Censorship


developer
01-23-2006, 08:25 PM
The moderators have choosen to censor the questions from Ernia, Tank and the others in the "NURBS modeling" thread by closing it. As they did not even worry about giving any explanation for this act i can only guess it was the fact they did not like the questions, as any discussion has been made impossible before it could even start. If there was any violation of the terms of use of this highly professional forum, which made censorship the only possible solution i would be very interested to get any infomation about this here.

Most of you around here have invested a lot of money and time in C4D, so it is pretty normal and understandable you are heavily biased against any kind of nonpositive information. And the ones who have been fooled are typically not proud about the fact itself.
I have invested much more time and much more money into Non Uniform Rational B-Splines, commonly abbreviated and referred to as NURBS, and other high potential companies did the same as me. NURBS has very high credibility and a perception of power in public as it is THE industry standard for freeform surfaces. Therefor many customers make it an important part of their buying-decision about a CG related software.

The maxon attorney Barbara H. Herr has stated in a letter on 20th of july in 2005 "Maxon has in no way and to no time reclaimed to offer NURBS".
Nobody could explain to me until now why maxon uses the term NURBS extensively anyhow.
I cant see any reason, except to make belief to potential customers that there are NURBS in Cinema4D. This concept is historically referred to as "the emperors new cloth". Everybody who dares to ask "Where are his clothes?" is rudely attacked: "Hang him high, he has made an insult against the emperor!"

For honest people there is a very simple and even for a little child understandable way to avoid any misunderstanding about things like that: they simply do not use the term. The others are in trouble now.

rgwarren
01-23-2006, 08:42 PM
Last I checked this wasn't a courtroom and most of us aren't lawyers. You must have thought you were in a courtroom. You're not.

Tell it to the judge not us.

imashination
01-23-2006, 09:17 PM
You claim to have developed a NURBS plugin, why don't you release it and show us your skills and abilities instead of making extremely vague threats to sue people? You do realise you can't sue a company because a single feature doesn't do what you expected right? You can ask for a refund, you could even ask them to rename something to make it clarer, but thats about as far as it goes. You knew c4d's NURBS style tools weren't on-par with a dedicated NURBS modeller ages ago, hence you claim to have made a NURBS plugin to fill the hole.

mikeh64
01-23-2006, 09:26 PM
yes, and Microsoft says it's OS is secure, and Apple says G5s are faster than PCs, my mom told me there was an Easter Bunny, I guess it's time to start sueing everyone for everything.

please persue your issue professionally via proper channels.

AdamT
01-23-2006, 09:30 PM
Get a clue, Developer. You have no claim against anyone. Moreover, you can't even articulate what you think your claim might be. And yes, I am an attorney.

LucentDreams
01-23-2006, 09:33 PM
The reasons for it beingclosed, as with this one, are that you are getting into legal situations which are far beyond the appropriate for this forum as with any other threads of this nature that always get closed. We could remove the threads if you prefer, but we let you get your word out, we would jsut liek to stop these before they get legally out of hand. CGtalk does not wish to be held liable in any such matter or involved in any way shpe or form.

keep it to the offices and courts and out of this forum.