A Spiritual City, Jaime Jasso (2D)

[I-NetGraFX]

This's pretty awesome! Interesting composition to look at.

Somehow I'm not sure where the light comes from.
Although there's overcast, there are different lightdirections in your matte painting (especially the treegroup to the very right). I think the lower right corner needs some more work (cloning artefacts, brush strokes, color values, etc..).

But this's just my opinion . . .
Anyway, keep up the good work! :)

Cheers, Daniel

[pierrebixquert]

it seems one you take care of enchanted.
very good composition.

[ervine]

Wow that looks pretty good! don't know about the tilitng of the camera though...

[celmar]

very good mood!... but there are also a lot of perspective problems!... the bacground part of the city seems not in the same perspective point than the foreground part; and the "angle" of the falls, in the middle, is impossible in perspective, too... anyway, maybe it's not important, after all!...

[theCloudmover]

You could probably nitpick this to death but overall I think this is FANTASTIC!!

:applause:

[jsandoval]

Admirable composite... maybe I could find too something to crit, but staring at the magnificient view distract me from doing that. Absolutamente impresionante, reminds me some scene in Episode II (Star wars).

[Kyena]

pardon my ignorance..but is it a manipulation or are there painted parts?

[tfwoods3]

Looks cool to me :) Would be nice to put a few people on the close tower.

[JJASSO]

hey guys thanks for your feedback, I appreciatte all your comments as well, about this image I did it all whit joining more than 70 photos togheter, and whit some 100% painted elements too little to watch , everything is from scratch as I was getting the photos I wanted, that why maybe in some building the perspective looks wrong or weird , but it is all I could do so far , yeah I really wanted to put some soldiers looking or watching trough the foreground tower I will do it later ,

thanks to all of you

[RLyons]

fantastic, 5 stars from me.

[xiaoyi]

very nice matte painting.is fantasy.This is personal suggestion.sorry.I think that if is I, I will plus in the distant place near the fortress a little more bird, thus a view will seem to be greatly.:)

[SpaceTik]

I love this! And the light's definately from the left. My only crit is that the distant water level is a bit too high.

[Rascal-VFX]

Superb matte, but i think mix b&w and color not so good in this option and i see different light dir.

[giza]

Great evocative landscape. Waterfalls are really well done.

[JJASSO]

thanks again for the comments and yes light is supposed to be from the left , but I guess it didn't work for some buildings.

[neutronic]

frontpage!! the water is incredible !

[Tilstrom]

Excellent job mate, very nice work. :)

[JJASSO]

this are just a few of the main photosho I used to build this city

http://img49.exs.cx/img49/6474/fotosbye.jpg

[Steveyola]

Beautiful.I can look at it for a long while man.Nice indeedy.:buttrock:

[AMoN-AMoK]

http://img121.exs.cx/img121/9084/garfield10.jpggood work, nice comp.

[subnurbs]

Very Inspiring... it might be interesting to do an evil/dark version of the compostion!

[ZombieFrog]

WOW! sooo much detail!

[clever_guy]

Great composition and imagination in pulling all the components together!!!

:applause:

-CG

[vortex3010]

Wow... I want to visit there! well all those photos just seem to bleed into each other cause i can't spot even the smallest seem. Great job!

[CGTalk Moderation]

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.