PDA

View Full Version : Max 6 can't cope with....


davemcd
08-24-2004, 02:03 AM
.... heirarchies longer than 15 items.

I just brought a new rig i was working on up to max 6, hit render and POW... application error. After much fussing about and tracking down the error i've traced it to the fact that if i create any heirarchy longer than 15 items deep then at render time Max falls over.

To try it yourself create a bone chain 15 - 20 items long and try to render it. From talking to some other colleagues its not every install that does it, but every single machine i've tried it on has had the problem.

Can other max 6 users try this and let me know if it crashes or not or if anyone finds a fix... the service pack 1 does crap all.

Other users on the max support boards have reported the same problems but as yet there's been no word in any of the threads from anyone associated with discreet. Its not really doing much to instill much confidence in updating to 6 let alone 7 when such a fundamental flaw exists.

Cheers,

DaveMcD

PS. I'm using an Athlon 3000 and the problem occured on 3 Athlons and one P4.

erilaz
08-24-2004, 02:15 AM
Hmmm... no problem here. I'll try a few more combinations.

erilaz
08-24-2004, 02:20 AM
Hmmm... I've added aother 15 or so to the 20-hierachy rig, animated a few areas and rendered, still no fuss. I barely register a spike in memory or performance as well.


Can you outline what you do exactly, with specs of the PCs? Maybe we can narrow it down.

EDIT: Just saw the cpus down the bottom of your post. How about memory? Operating system etc. :D

davemcd
08-24-2004, 02:58 AM
Using win XP pro SP1, Geforce FX 5600 on my machine various cards and drivers on the other machines. I've got 1 GB Ram pretty sure its Kingston. 2 x 512MB.

I dont even get to the animate part... I just create the chain and hit render.

It doesnt even have to be bones... it can be any heirarchy. I can create 15 - 20 boxes link them one to the other in a chain and the same thign happens.

DaveMcD

Scotti Leslie
08-24-2004, 06:35 AM
davemcd,
My P4ht 2.8, 1024 RAM, has Max6 sp1, and I cant find an upper limit yet. I am watching
48 animated boxes, linked and rotating and it renders fine. I did a bone chain over 30 long
and added arms with IK, and no prob. It renders out fine. Hmmm...

Taoizm
08-24-2004, 01:46 PM
Odd, I've given this a try at home and work, and no issues with either.

peekoot
08-24-2004, 03:20 PM
200 bone IK chain working here just fine... i suppose i could go much furhter... you've got me scared for a while... :)

P4 2,4, 1gig ram, gforce ti4200 128mb ram, win2k sp4

davemcd
08-25-2004, 01:59 AM
well i'm kinda glad no-one else here is experiencing this problem cos its really really annoying... hmmm.... does anyone else still have max 5 installed at the same time... cos I do... i wonder if thats perhaps the cause of the problem.

DaveMcD

erilaz
08-25-2004, 05:13 AM
Nope, still have max 5 installed with max 6 here and no problems. Hmm.. this is a bit of a doozy for you.

CGTalk Moderation
01-19-2006, 01:00 AM
This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.