Still: Rose

[Faithbleed]

Not Bad. I'ts a little too perfect, it lacks the imperfections a real rose does. The Shaders could use some work. Maybe add a texture for some colour blending and a bump map or dispalcement for the imperfections. Oh and the stem and the leaves dont look right. Sorry if I baggin on ya. :)

[Plays_4_Pants]

Rose petals fold and bend and crinkle and have texture to them even on top of all those things. So do the stems. A close up study has to have those things. This rose may be good as a far away prop though

[Mancora]

I think it works, when i look at that i think its a rose which is purposly trying to be fake in a cartoonish CG way, and not be a perfect rose, in which case any "miss" from it being a real reproduction would be points off.

I definatly like it :)

[3dnirvana]

Thanks guys!

I was going for a perfect rose look because my client wanted a flawless look to everything on his website.

[percydaman]

it looks okay. could use some more work. possibly textures

[HenningK]

What he means by "too perfect" is too computery. The most perfect Rose would be rich with texture... thorns... translucent petals... and it would also lie flat on a surface. This is okay as a symbol maybe.
-hen

[CGTalk Moderation]

This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.