threedsquid
11-11-2011, 06:19 PM
I recently got a rejection on one of my image “The Dark Knight (http://threedsquid.cgsociety.org/gallery/1017999/)”
The explanation is regarding the image ‘have an artistic problem’ or ‘offending some people’, and ‘need more creative presentation’ I guess the emails are an automated one. But I really need to know more explanation about that.
As far as I know, this image looks finished. I’ve seen other simple renders, or front shot only with simple pose that still accepted in the gallery.
I don’t see this image offend anyone. And most of all, I did present the image with effort. It’s not just a plain render, I gave it a background, I gave it textures, some effects and rework the colors in Photoshop.
If there are some new criteria that cgsociety applied, that I might not be aware of, then I would love to know. To the moderators, it will be nice to hear some feedbacks
Thanks,
Marthin
The explanation is regarding the image ‘have an artistic problem’ or ‘offending some people’, and ‘need more creative presentation’ I guess the emails are an automated one. But I really need to know more explanation about that.
As far as I know, this image looks finished. I’ve seen other simple renders, or front shot only with simple pose that still accepted in the gallery.
I don’t see this image offend anyone. And most of all, I did present the image with effort. It’s not just a plain render, I gave it a background, I gave it textures, some effects and rework the colors in Photoshop.
If there are some new criteria that cgsociety applied, that I might not be aware of, then I would love to know. To the moderators, it will be nice to hear some feedbacks
Thanks,
Marthin