PDA

View Full Version : Animation: 3D Short: Animalada

Emiliano
11-06-2003, 11:23 AM
Hello Everybody,
The video short is as you see it, with good and bads and we are not trying to improve the video.
But the specific critique that we would like to hear itīs about the music... or the general audio. This point are in an evolving stage.

http://www.animalada.com/videos/Pelotazo_01_web_480.mov 34 mb Quicktime.

http://www.animalada.com/videos/animalada_pelotazo.mpg
same video but lighter 14 mb. Mpeg VCD


If this serve as a guide we would like feedback on these topics:

1. If you like the it in general
2. If you like the music style
3. If you donīt like it. Please specify why
a - Do you think it does not fit ?
b - Itīs style is strange ?
c - What do you suggest
d - You donīt know why but yoy expected something else.
4. What about Music Quality ?
5. and Audio Fx Quality ?
6. Overall punctuaction. 1=crap / 10=best that could be.

Please tell us if you have been with objective or subjective judgement, both opinions are good !!! :)

Have in mind that these video is directed to a wide audience. Children mostly but adults as well.
As always, thank you all.

Emiliano
Animalada
Omnicrola
11-06-2003, 08:45 PM
1. If you like the it in general
2. If you like the music style
3. If you donīt like it. Please specify why
a - Do you think it does not fit ?
b - Itīs style is strange ?
c - What do you suggest
d - You donīt know why but yoy expected something else.
4. What about Music Quality ?
5. and Audio Fx Quality ?
6. Overall punctuaction. 1=crap / 10=best that could be.

1) liked it
2) appropriate music, very light, comical
3) has some problems
a) some of the run cycles do not keep in time with the ground, and there is no establishing shot as to why the grass is suddenly growing, in fact we never see the label on the bottle until the end credits. great laugh track though. :)
b) good style
c) the sky does not match the lighting style, either brighten the sky, or darken the lighting
d) ---

5) Audio is good, could use a good "CLANG" when he smacks into the goal post

6) 5 out of 10
CGTalk Moderation
01-16-2006, 02:00 PM
This thread has been automatically closed as it remained inactive for 12 months. If you wish to continue the discussion, please create a new thread in the appropriate forum.